The Light That Gets Through: Managing Caregiver Guilt

As I was watching one of my favorite mystery shows, the villain suddenly said, “There’s a crack in everything... that is how the light gets through.” The line, from Leonard Cohen’s song “Anthem,” stayed with me, especially as I was preparing for a talk with a group of caregivers later that day. It seemed to sum up so much about the caregiving journey. The cracks represent imperfection and struggle, ultimately allowing the light of hope to shine through.

Perfection is impossible. Many caregivers of children with serious illnesses wrestle with feeling like they are not enough. Or they feel like they are not doing enough for their loved ones. They may even feel guilty for having needs of their own. Wanting to make things better—perfect—is a natural response to watching someone suffer. It is an attempt to gain control in a situation that may feel uncontrollable.

Caregivers want to protect their children. They may even blame themselves for their child’s illness. As a caregiver, you may have moved beyond denial, put on your superhero cape, and stepped into the role of protector and savior. But no one can be perfect, and that cape can get incredibly heavy. Over time, the relentless responsibility of caregiving can breed feelings of resentment, anger, and guilt. This is the crack.

It is hard to admit these feelings. To keep that crack from getting wider, caregivers often turn anger, resentment, fear, or sadness inward. They try to glue life back together. But perfection is unreachable, no matter how desperately you try.

Healthy guilt versus toxic guilt

“I did something wrong.” 

For caregivers, guilt often comes even when you are doing everything right. You might feel guilty for being angry, wanting time for yourself, or losing patience. This guilt is a signal that something is not right. But how you respond makes all the difference.

• Healthy guilt motivates change. It is a natural response when you have made a mistake or acted against your values. It helps you apologize, adjust, and grow.
• Toxic guilt is an ongoing, excessive feeling of shame or responsibility, even when you have not done anything wrong. It is fueled by unrealistic expectations, perfectionism, and “shoulds” that say, “I am never doing enough.” This guilt leads to overthinking and exhaustion.

Many caregivers do not struggle because they are not doing enough. They struggle because they have internalized impossible standards of caregiving. It is time to let go of perfectionism and let the light shine in. Forgive yourself and remember you are not failing—you are exhausted.

How to shift your thoughts

When thoughts like, “I should do more” arise, notice them without judgment, and gently replace them with, “I am showing up with love, not perfection.” Instead of blaming yourself, say, “I am doing my best with what I have right now.”

Simple tools like practicing mindfulness, calming your breath to soothe your body, or taking a moment to enjoy a beautiful day can help your mind and body recover from stress. When everything feels overwhelming, focus on the simple task right in front of you. 

Other ways to help manage stress and focus on the positive include:

• Write in a journal.
• Talk to your care team about your child’s treatment and support options.
• Do something fun for yourself.
• Set time limits on thinking about guilt.
• Spend time in nature.
• Call a friend or loved one.

Zen master Thich Nhat Hanh told a story of crowded refugee boats crossing the ocean. “If even one person on the boat stayed calm, it was enough. It showed the way for everyone to survive.” If you can stay calm and be gentle to yourself, it can show the way for others around you. 

You may not control the storm, but you can steady your boat.

Find more information